vs
ANALYSIS VERDICT

Findymail leads on autonomy (71 vs 68), while LeadMagic starts at $99/mo. Select LeadMagic for high phone match rate across us mid-market and enterprise; consider Findymail if you prioritize outstanding catch-all email resolution algorithm.

Metric / Feature
Autonomy Score (AES)
68/100
71/100
Value-to-Cost Ratio3.753.75
Starting Price$99/mo$99/mo
Pricing Modelpaidpaid
Primary Strengths
  • High phone match rate across US mid-market and enterprise
  • Direct integration into Clay workflows without code
  • Cost-effective pay-as-you-go credits
  • Outstanding catch-all email resolution algorithm
  • First-class integration with Clay tables
  • Direct Sales Navigator and Apollo scraper extension
Tradeoffs
  • Pure data API without built-in outbound sequence manager
  • Smaller platform footprint than legacy enterprise vendors
  • Focused purely on email finding (no phone numbers)
  • Credit plans require monitoring for high-volume scrapers
Common Integrations

Clay, Smartlead, Instantly

Unique Integrations

Webhooks

API, Google Sheets

Pricing tier comparison

LeadMagic tiers

Essential
$99 /month
  • 5,000 credits/mo (≈ 5k emails or 1k mobiles)
  • Search included · 10k exports/day
  • Search API · 1 credit/result
  • Finder & Validation · 300 RPM each
  • API, CLI & MCP access
  • Clay, Apollo & Zapier integrations
Growth
$249 /month
  • 20,000 credits/mo (≈ 20k emails or 4k mobiles)
  • Search included · 25k exports/day
  • Finder & Validation · 600 RPM each
  • Everything in Essential
  • Slack support & dedicated success rep
Professional
$499 /month
  • 50,000 credits/mo (≈ 50k emails or 10k mobiles)
  • Search included · 50k exports/day
  • Finder & Validation · 1,000 RPM each
  • Everything in Growth
  • Team analytics & custom data mapping help
Ultimate
$849 /month
  • 100,000 credits/mo
  • Search included · 100k exports/day
  • Finder & Validation · 1,500 RPM each
  • Everything in Professional
  • Dedicated engineering channel

Findymail tiers

Individual
$99 /month
  • 1 seat
  • 5 active signals
Team
$399 /month
  • 5 seats
  • 25 active signals
Scale
$999 /month
  • 20 seats
  • 100 active signals

Neither quite right? Tell us your team and budget and we'll pick the top 3.

Get matched

Tell us what you need and we'll show the three best-scored tools right away. Recommendations come from the index, not from who pays.

Related comparisons